Carpet Removal in Boise: Is There Hardwood Underneath?

It's a common surprise with carpet removal: the old carpet comes up and there's red oak underneath that's been there the whole time. Sometimes the homeowner has already put a deposit down on new carpet.

That happens more than you'd think. If you're planning carpet removal in Boise and your house was built before about 1960, there's a real chance hardwood is hiding under the pad. Here's how to find out before anyone starts cutting.

Which Boise homes usually have hardwood

Age is the biggest clue. A lot of older houses in the North End, the East End, the Boise Bench and around Vista were built with solid oak or fir floors. Wall-to-wall carpet caught on in the '60s and '70s, and plenty of people laid it right over the wood.

Newer houses are a different story. Most tract homes built in Meridian, Nampa and south Boise from the '80s on have plywood or OSB subfloor under the carpet, and there's nothing to save.

If your house sits on a slab, you'll find concrete. Maybe some old glue too, which is its own project.

A 1990s two-story in Meridian? Probably not. A 1948 brick ranch near Boise State? Definitely worth a look.

How to check before carpet removal day

You don't need to pull up a whole room. Pick a corner nobody sees, like inside a closet or behind the couch.

Grab needle-nose pliers and pull the carpet up off the tack strip right at the corner. A firm tug usually pops it loose. Fold it back, then peel back a few inches of pad.

Here's what you might see:

When you're done, press the carpet back onto the tack strip with your palm or a knee. Nobody will know you were there.

Check more than one spot if you can. In some houses the living room has nice oak while a back bedroom that was added on later is plywood. Hallways and closets sometimes got patched over the years too.

Heads up: If you find those small square tiles, stop there. Tile from that era, and the black glue under it, sometimes contains asbestos, which isn't a problem sitting still but is once it gets scraped or broken. Get a sample tested before anyone pulls it up.

Is the wood actually worth saving?

Finding hardwood doesn't mean it's in good shape. Carpet protects the surface, but pet urine soaks right through the pad and can turn oak boards black.

While you've got the corner peeled back, look for dark stains, cupped boards, or gaps wide enough to slide a nickel into. Paint drips along the baseboards are common too, left by whoever painted the walls with the carpet still down.

Most surface stuff sands out. Deep black stains usually mean swapping out a few boards, and a good flooring person can weave new ones in so you'd never notice.

Solid oak strip floors can handle several sandings over their life, so even a rough-looking floor is usually salvageable. A local refinisher can tell you in one visit, and most will give you a quote for free.

Money-wise, what sanding and refinishing costs depends on the square footage, how many boards need replacing, how deep the stains go and the finish you pick. Get a refinishing quote and a price for new carpet with pad and install, and compare them side by side. The oak will outlast the carpet by decades.

Honestly? Beat-up oak usually comes back nicer than people expect. We've seen some pretty sad floors turn out great.

What careful carpet removal looks like over hardwood

This is where the job changes. Tearing carpet off plywood is fast, and nobody cares if the subfloor gets scuffed. Pulling it off oak you want to keep takes more patience.

Here's what we do differently:

• Cut the carpet into strips with the blade angled so it doesn't score the wood
• Slide a putty knife under the pry bar when lifting tack strips so the bar doesn't dent the boards
• Pull every pad staple instead of snapping them off flush
• Roll the strips and carry them out instead of dragging them across the floor

The staples are the tedious part. Older pads were stapled every few inches, so one bedroom can have hundreds. If they snap off, your refinisher has to dig them out later, and a sander hitting a staple isn't fun for anybody.

Plan on it taking longer than a standard tear-out. How much longer depends on the size of the room, how many staples and tack strips there are, and whether there are stairs or closets to work around.

Whoever does your [carpet removal](/demolition/carpet-removal), tell them there's hardwood underneath so they show up ready for it.

Should you pull it up yourself?

This is a pretty doable weekend project if you've got a utility knife, a flat bar, pliers, and knees that still cooperate.

What people underestimate is the hauling. Rolled carpet and pad are bulky and heavy, and a single room's worth takes up more of a pickup bed than you'd guess.

Trickling it into your curbside cart over a month gets old, and Idaho Youth Ranch won't take used carpet. Most DIYers end up driving it out to Hidden Hollow, the Ada County landfill, and paying at the gate.

It makes more sense to call someone when there are several rooms, stairs, or a refinisher already booked for next Tuesday.

The bottom line: before you pay for new flooring, spend a few minutes in a closet corner with a pair of pliers. If there's oak under there, you could save a good chunk of money, and the removal just takes a little more care.

If you'd rather hand off the cutting, the staples and the dump run, give us a call at (208) 593-2877. We'll come take a look and give you a straight answer about our [carpet removal service](/demolition/carpet-removal), no pressure either way.